From: Marlee
At a very early age boys and girls are taught to close off
themselves from one another and to look focus on their differences and not
their similarities (Rudman 2015). This true in the way we speak. The saying “like a girl” can
be used after just about any verb. You can “run like a girl”, throw “like a
girl”, act “like a girl”, and even walk “like a girl”. The sky is the limit
when it comes to degrading young girls. We make it a point to treat aggression
and strength as manly traits, and weakness and passive behavior as feminine
traits. We give no room for anything else. You either act like a girl, or you
are one. The idea that girls are somehow less capable then boys to boy things
and vice-versa is not true. This can be proven through girls like my sister.
Girls at a young age are discouraged to play sports. They
are taught to nurture or put into activities such as dance or pageants that
focus purely on their beauty. My photo is of my younger sister Emma. She eleven
and one of strongest girls I know. Emma plays soccer and follows soccer like it’s
her religion. She’s carried her team to County Championships and helped them
win at those championships and helped them win their division. Emma has played
on a soccer team with all boys, and when the coach would yell “You boys are
playing like girls” he would quickly retract his statement and make it a point
to apologize to Emma and compliment her on skills in comparison to the boys.
In my picture I made emphasis on the gaze of Emma is
starring right at the camera. This is done to connect with the viewer. It
touches the viewer directly. It makes the viewer feel almost as if they have a
fault in this issue. Her gaze represents how girls look to society for their
worth. The phrase “like a girl” is used in mass media and has become a norm to
describe one’s actions across America. When girls see this in their media and
hear these words coming from those, they love the most, they start to lose
faith in their own capabilities. After some boys in out neighborhood bullied my
little sister about her skills in her young soccer career, she came inside
crying and feeling defeated and asked our mother “What is so wrong about being
girl?” No one should feel shame about who they are or who they are destined to
come.
Another emphasis I made in my photo is my background. I made
the background and empty space to represent the capabilities of girls. IF as a
society we promoted the same things for girls that we did for women, both women
and men wouldn’t feel so limited in their spheres. The reason why I kept the
space so empty is to represent the non-conformity of Emma. She doesn’t conform
to the standards that she is somehow less than because she is a girl. She keeps
her spheres open for anything that comes her way, no matter if people think its
masculine or feminine
The last piece I emphasized in the photo was the lines. The
line of the net symbolizes webbing. These lines as webbing, represent the
“webbing” that make up girls’ lives. Everything we teach children at a young
age shaped who they are. From their morals to their politics, the “webbing” in
their childhood is essential to every person’s life. Without proper webbing a
child could be left with a broken set of moral. Webbing makes people decide who
they want to become. IF girls webbing encourages them to take subordinate
rolls, and make them feel lesser than, than girls will choose a life for
themselves that embodies this.
In Conclusion, the “Like a Girl” Ideal not only destroys
young girls’ self-confidence, limits their scopes, and makes the feel unequal
to a boy, but destroys their hope for a future where the amount to same as a
boy.
Works Cited
Rudman, Laurie A., et al. "The Two Cultures of
Childhood." The Social Psychology of Gender: How Power and Intimacy Shape
Gender Relations. The Guilford Press, 2015, 59-63.
5 comments:
Hey Marlee,
I loved your idea and your essay and the creative techniques you picked went along perfect with it! Some spins I would have done with your essay would be including foreground. The girl’s shirt perfectly explains the photo with it saying, “I know I play like a girl try to keep up”. Color would be a potential factor I would’ve included because she is wearing a broad spectrum of colors not just pink or blue, but both and every color in between proving girls and boys can wear any color no matter their gender. I would have used camera angle, but not in the same way as you. I would have had the young girl looking up at the camera and explain how much of superhero she is in that sense by looking up to the world. Finally, I love the webbing angle you worked into the essay I would have never thought of it myself! However, if I did, I would have included how the webbing represents each individuals’ obstacles and accomplishments in life. We’re all wired the same way but each of us go through different things and come from different paths.
-H.F.
From: Maddie
Marlee, your post really drew me in as I, and I’m sure many other girls can relate to this topic. As a kid I grew up in a neighborhood with a lot of boys, and I loved playing all the games that would be considered “for boys.” I’ve been playing sports since I was four and I can tell you from multiple experiences, if you beat any guy in these games or sports, it wasn’t that you were strong or good, it’s “I went easy on you since you’re a girl,” even if it’s not true. You would think that as maturity hits and you learn more, mindsets would change but just a few weeks ago, I was throwing a football and my male friend said “You throw good for a girl.” It isn’t like it’s a huge deal so I didn’t say anything, but I clearly knew that gender stereotypes exist all around us, even people close to us. I don’t even think any of the boys mentioned took a second thought about what they said, and they probably weren’t even trying to be offensive in a lot of cases. This is the mindset that’s been pushed on all of us since we were born.
From Maddie Turner
Marlee, the photo that you used really emphasized how girls are kind of perceived as weak. Although the image is trying to represent a strong independent girl trying to prove that a girl is just as strong as a guy, it is still claiming that women need to prove themselves. The blurred background shows the emphasis on the main subject which is the girl. The net behind her shows line, and it also shows that she is centered. Although the background is blurred it is still an image of a soccer net. This soccer net represents the sport that she plays. The serious look on the girls face shows that she is up for the challenge, and I am not sure if this challenge is supposed to be made towards the other team or if it is supposed to be made towards men in general. The person is staring right at the camera and this shows that she is superior to them. The angle is straight on and this also shows dominance towards the camera. Growing up I too faced problems of being told I wasn’t good enough because I was a girl. I was always picked last for kick ball when I was younger, but I grew and became one of the best in the state. I was named all state in high school. So okay I might play like a girl, but what is playing like a guy exactly?
Hi Marlee,
I like your photo of having a young girl stand in front of a soccer goal which represents her standing strong in front of the gender norms. Typically girls are weak and frail but this picture proves that girls are just as strong as guys and have the same capabilities as them. I like how she’s wearing a shirt that talks about how girls play, usually shirts promote guys being stronger and better in sports, however this shirt promotes girls being stronger and better. By wearing this shirt she’s being bold because its seen as her fighting against the gender norms of boys being more athletic. I like how you have her looking directly into the camera because it shows her being fearless and bold by making eye contact with the audience which is better than having her gaze be away from the camera which shows fear, and she’s disproving that. A creative technique you could have added was having the camera angle looking down from the point of view of society of how girls shouldn’t be playing sports because it’s a “manly” thing to do. Society assumes girls should not play sports and be competitive, however they should do more nurturing activities such as being at the house taking care of the families. If they did do competitive sports it would be something more girly such as what you mentioned in your writing, doing pageants or dance. Society thinks girls should focus on beauty whereas guys should focus on activities that make them seem more manly and stronger.
From: Valerie
As a girl who grew up playing sports and was considered a “tomboy”, I relate to your photo a lot. I like that you had your sister hold the gaze with the viewer to make them feel ‘uncomfortable’ and show her strength despite society wanting her to conform. However, I think I would have made the background bigger to make her feel smaller and emphasize the pressure surrounding her. Or changed the angle of the picture, for the same reasoning. I think either of those would create a better contrast but with the gaze you already captured would still keep your point. I think also somehow incorporating a boy could have deepened the argument also. But I love that her hair is pulled back to defy beauty standards for girls and that her shirt’s logo strengthens that point. I also like that the photo is simple but keeping it that way really packs a strong punch.
-NT
Post a Comment